One nation, one language?
One of the core policies of the current Indian administration has been to focus on promoting Hindi as India’s common language. The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) led by Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Home Secretary Amit Shah have continued to push Hindi as the ‘one’ language of India since the party won the national elections in 2014.
This idea of ‘one nation, one language’ made national headlines on September 14th 2019 when at an event to mark Hindi Divas (also known as National Hindi day) Amit Shah claimed that Hindi is the country’s ‘uniting’ language, because ‘most’ people speak it. Shah tweeted that: “India is a country of different languages and every language has its own importance but it is very important to have a language of the whole country which should become the identity of India globally,” To try to appeal to Indians to increase their use of Hindi, Shah suggested that it was the aspiration of Mahatma Gandhi and Sardar Patel to have one common language for the country.
As noted in the previous section through the use of the example of Punjab, language politics within India has historically been violent and painful – the 1950s and 60s saw the fervent resistance to the imposition of Hindi. This resistance continues today. Not only in Punjab, but in states throughout India. States in the South such as Kerala, Tamil Nadu and Karnataka, like Punjab, have also historically resisted the imposition of Hindi.
In direct response to Shah’s comments the Kerala chief minister, Pinarayi Vijayan said that “The claim that Hindi can unite the country is absurd” and that Shah’s comments “…can only be seen as a battle cry against people who love and treat their mother tongues as their own mother.”
Since the BJP came into power in 2014 there have been numerous attempts made by them to promote hindi as India’s common language.
In 2014, the Home Ministry ordered that “government employees and officials of all ministries, departments, corporations or banks who have made official accounts on social networking sites should give priority to Hindi”. After being heavily criticised, the order was later revoked.
In June 2019, India’s Human Resources Development Ministry unveiled the draft of a new educational policy which sought to make Hindi mandatory in all schools across India. The government soon dropped the provision that stipulated that Hindi had to be one of the languages that students should study in Grade 6 after protests from political parties.
The BJP’s efforts to promote Hindi abroad are also noteworthy. According to data from the Anadolu agency, the government has spent 484 million rupees ($6.4 million) on promoting Hindi at the UN and world capitals to make Hindi an official UN language (Currently, there are six official languages of the UN. These are Arabic, Chinese, English, French, Russian and Spanish). In March 2018, the Indian government signed a 2 year memorandum with the UN secretariat with the aim being to increase the Hindi content produced by the UN.
Looking specifically at Punjab, upon inspection it becomes evident through the examination of governmental and institutional language attitudes and policies that efforts have been made to exclude Punjabi from both public and private life.
Looking at the case of the state’s private education system, Shamandeep Singh, Founder and CEO of Sikhi Awareness Foundation (SAF) draws attention to the oppression of Punjabi in private schools.
Citing his own first hand experience, he comments that: “Working in the education sector, I’ve come across many cases where children were asked to speak either Hindi or English in school. If they couldn’t or refused, they were told to stay home.”
Similar comments have also been made by parents of children who attend private schools. “Both my daughters are made to speak either English or Hindi in the school. They now speak Hindi at home also even though we talk to them in Punjabi. Children are following the trend as they feel it would not be good to speak in Punjabi” commented Dipin Chawla, a resident from Phagwara in a Times of India article.
In the same article, Meera Javed, Jalandhar’s Apee Jay School’s principal, also admitted that Hindi is preferred to Punjabi suggesting that “in any case students will get fluent in Punjabi at home”.
H.B Kaur, the principal of Swami Sant Dass Public School notes that the usual trend is to prefer Hindi over Punjabi. “The biggest issue with this trend is that schools are creating inferiority complex amongst students about their mother tongue.”
Linguistics professor J.S Paur comments that: “Though Shiromani Akali Dal spearheaded the agitation for Punjabi Suba, it did little for promotion of Punjabi language”.
The Punjabi government’s Education Department wrote to the chairman of the Council Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) and the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) in 2019 and requested for them to adhere to the guidelines of the Punjabi and other Languages Act (PLA) 2008, which made it mandatory to teach Punjabi as a compulsory subject in schools in the state up to class X. It had been brought to the attention of the state department that many of the private schools in the state who were affiliated with ICSE and CBSE were not adhering to the provisions of the act.
In March 2020, a resolution was passed by the Punjab Assembly to make Punjabi mandatory in all schools from class 1 to 10. While government schools had been providing compulsory Punjabi lessons from 2008, private schools had not been.
This resolution aims to make these same lessons compulsory in private schools too. On the resolution, Shamandeep Singh, a keen advocate commented that: “As somebody who champions early childhood development and the preservation of the Punjabi language, I applaud this belated decision by the Punjab Government”.
While it is yet to be seen what the impact of this resolution will be, it is most definitely a step in the right direction.
A recent example of legislative discriminiation against the language of Punjabi can be seen as recent as September 2020 after Punjabi was excluded from Jammu and Kashmir Official Languages Bill that was passed in the same month. It is estimated that 13 lakh Punjabi speakers reside in the area. In a debate on the bill, Minister of State for Home Affairs, G. Kishan Reddy articulated that it was a long-standing demand of the people of Jammu and Kashmir that all of the languages spoken in the region should be included in the list of official languages.
He stated that: “The J&K Constitution included Punjabi and the first Chief Minister of J&K was a Punjabi” and added: “It hurts the feelings of those who are settled there. I would urge the government to reconsider because language is the basis of cultural heritage of the community.”
Other examples where Punjabi has been neglected in the state itself, albeit in a more subtle way, can be seen in the omission of Punjabi from road signs and inauguration plaques.
(Members of the Malwa Youth Federation deface road signs in Bathinda on Saturday. A TRIBUNE PHOTO)
In October 2017, members of various youth foundations defaced road signs as part of a campaign called ‘saving Punjabi’.
Organisations such as the Malwa Youth Federation went around the city of Bathinda and blackend the English and Hindi signboards using black paint. When the police tried to intervene, they began a road blockage agitation accusing “the administration of being hand in glove with the Central Government and working towards promoting English and Hindi in Punjab.”
Youth leader Lakha Sidhana commented that “Despite the fact that Punjabi is our mother tongue, it has been relegated to the third place on signboards after English and Hindi. It is also shocking to see that at some places, the boards don’t even use Punjabi. The language is not being given the respect and importance that it deserves”.
Dal Khalsa vice-president, Baba Hardip Singh was in agreement with Sidhana and stated: “If we lose our touch with our mother tongue, we will also be out of touch with our history, culture, traditions, literature and values. We will not let this happen as it is not good for the present as well as the future generations.”
The Tribune India reported that “after lifting the blockade, the protestors convened a meeting. It was decided that in case the state government failed in getting the Central Government departments to give due respect to Punjabi at public places and keeping it on a pedestal higher than that for English and Hindi, the organisations would continue to blacken the road signs”.
In a similar vein, At the inauguration of the Kartarpur corridor in November 2019 (The Kartarpur Corridor is a visa-free border crossing and corridor, connecting the Gurdwara Darbar Sahib in Pakistan to the border with India) Punjabi was omitted from the official inauguration board while Hindi and English were included.
Punjab Minister Tript Rajinder Singh Bajwa commented that: “It is highly unfortunate that the inscription on the inauguration board was in Hindi followed by English while Punjabi, which is the state’s official language, has been ignored which amounts to blatant injustice with the state,” in an official statement.